TL;DR: For most first-time sellers, the printful vs printify choice comes down to fewer variables versus a lower base price. Printful prints in its own facilities plus a partner network and publishes a price list for branding. Printify is a marketplace of third-party print providers. Its base prices tend to run lower, and quality depends on the provider you pick. Both are free to start at $0. Hold off on Printify Premium until your monthly product spend clears about $195, or on Printful Growth until it clears about $76. Both are best-case figures.
Disclosure: ES Club earns a commission from Printful, Printify and Shopify through links in this article. We earn from both sides of this comparison, so we have no reason to pick one. We earn nothing from Gelato.
You have probably already chosen print on demand and now need a supplier. If you are undecided on the model, dropshipping vs print on demand is the comparison that works through that choice.
Printful vs Printify at a glance
Printful vs Printify is a choice between one company running much of its own printing and a marketplace of printers. This table compares the 2026 plans, discounts and fees listed on each company's pricing page, checked on October 25, 2026.
| Printful | Printify | |
|---|---|---|
| Production | Own facilities plus a partner network | Network of third-party print providers |
| Free plan | $0 with access to 589 products | $0 with 5 stores per account |
| Paid plan | Growth at $24.99/month, 14-day trial | Premium at $39/month or $299/year, 10 stores |
| Advertised discount | Up to 33% off products, 9% off branding | Up to 20% off all products, up to 33% on new products and custom branding |
| Paid plan terms | Growth is free once sales reach $12K/year | Premium is non-refundable, cancel before renewal |
| Branding | Inside label $0.99, outside label $2.49 | Check the provider |
| Samples | 20% off on Free, 25% off on Growth, 1 sample order a month, 3 items max | Check your account |

The same company owns both, and that changes how you read the reviews
Printful and Printify announced their merger on November 5, 2024 and now run as separate brands under one holding company. A Printful vs Printify comparison therefore weighs two products from one owner. The rivalry most reviews describe no longer exists at the ownership level.
The Printful Printify merger left both platforms running on their own. Alex Saltonstall, Printful's former CEO, leads the combined company. Podbase refers to the parent as FYUL, though that name comes from secondary sources.
Who writes the comparisons matters as well. We checked the US results for this keyword on October 25, 2026. Vendors held two of the seven organic spots:
- Printful, position 6: Its ranking page is its own "Printify alternatives" post, so the company is reviewing a sister brand.
- Podbase, position 3: This print-on-demand supplier ranks with a comparison that ends on its own product. It still lists Premium at $29 in an update from July 2026.
- Bootstrapping Ecommerce, position 1: This is the one independent article in the results, published in September 2025, and it also shows $29.
Reddit, YouTube, Quora and a Facebook group filled the other four spots. We earn from both brands too, so check the arithmetic here for yourself.
How do Printful and Printify actually make products?
Printful prints in its own facilities and adds a partner network on top. Printify connects you to third-party print providers and leaves the choice of printer to you. That difference decides what a quality complaint about either brand tells you.
Printful: One company, its own facilities
Printful gives you one catalog and one price list, with 589 products on the Free plan. You make fewer decisions, and there are fewer printers to vet. The trade-off is price, because Printful's base cost tends to sit above Printify's. Its partner network also means not every order comes from the same building, so a sample still matters.
Printify: A marketplace of print providers
Printify is a marketplace, so "Printify quality" is not one thing. Each provider has its own location, reviews and price, and those three decide most of what your customer receives.
For example, a bad review of a Printify shirt tells you about one provider on one order. It says little about the provider you might pick. The lower price comes with more homework.
What does each one really cost per order?
The printify vs printful gap looks wide on base price alone. Each order also carries shipping, tax and any branding or image fees. Compare the total for one delivered order, since the cheapest blank may not make the cheapest parcel.
Bootstrapping Ecommerce's September 2025 comparison put a Gildan 64000 tee at $12.95 on Printful and $7.25 on Printify Premium. Treat that $5.70 gap as an illustration. The figures are a year old and unconfirmed at the source. The Printify price also assumes you pay for Premium.
| Line item | Printful | Printify Premium |
|---|---|---|
| Gildan 64000 base price | $12.95 | $7.25 (varies by provider) |
| Inside label | $0.99 | Check the provider |
| One Premium Image | $1 | Check the provider |
| Subtotal with those options | $14.94 | $7.25 plus any branding |
| Shipping and tax | Charged separately | Check at order |
Printful's pricing page lists an inside label at $0.99 and an outside label at $2.49. Premium Images cost $1 per image, per placement, per item sold. Embroidery adds $2.95 to $6.50 once for digitizing, plus $2.95 for an extra placement. With an inside label and one Premium Image, that $12.95 tee becomes $14.94 before shipping and tax. The gap grows to $7.69 before any Printify branding cost.
Printify charges no platform or listing fees. It earns its margin inside the fulfillment price. The number you see already includes its cut.

The supplier is one line of the budget. What it costs to start a Shopify store is the breakdown that goes through the rest.
Printify Premium vs Printful Growth: When the subscription pays off
A subscription pays off only when its discount is worth more than its fee. At the maximum advertised discount, Printify Premium needs about $195 a month in product spend on monthly billing. Printful Growth needs about $76.
Printify raised Premium from $29 to $39 a month on February 17, 2026. The annual price stayed at $299 ($24.99 a month). Pages still quoting $29 imply a break-even of $145, which is $50 too low for anyone paying monthly.
| Plan | Monthly fee | Max discount | Break-even at max | Break-even at half |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Printify Premium, monthly | $39 | 20% | $195 | $390 |
| Printify Premium, annual | $24.99 | 20% | About $125 | About $250 |
| Printful Growth | $24.99 | 33% | About $76 | About $150 |
These are our estimates, calculated as the fee divided by the discount. Premium advertises up to 20% off all products, and Growth up to 33% off products and 9% off branding. Those are "up to" figures, so read the break-even at max as a floor. If your products earn half the maximum, a monthly Premium plan needs $390 a month. Annual Premium needs about $250 and Growth about $150. Below those lines, the Free plan is cheaper.
The terms that change the math
Printify does not refund the Premium fee, and you have to cancel before the renewal date. The annual plan means paying $299 up front, so it suits a store that already clears the line. Premium also raises the store limit from 5 to 10. It advertises up to 33% off new products and custom branding, so a store buying mostly those items breaks even sooner.
Growth comes with a 14-day trial and 25% off samples. It becomes free once sales reach $12K a year, or $1,000 a month on average.
With no orders yet, neither plan can pay for itself. Start on Free and revisit the decision when a month of real product spend clears the line.

Shipping, duties and where your customers live
Shipping cost and delivery speed depend heavily on where a product is printed relative to the customer. The US ended its de minimis exemption for all countries on August 29, 2025. A parcel printed abroad now clears customs and carries duty.
Separate two numbers that published comparisons often blend. Fulfillment time is how long the printer takes to make the item. Shipping time is how long the carrier takes after that. The figures we found mixed the two and could not be traced to either company, so we leave them out. Your own sample orders will give you a better number.
Printful charges shipping and tax separately from the product price, so its pricing page will not show your full cost. On Printify, provider location is a choice you make for each product.
For example, a seller with mostly US buyers might find a cheap provider overseas. Once duty lands on each parcel, the lower base price can disappear. Before you list, check where the provider prints and how duty is handled on your orders.
Where Gelato fits
Gelato is the third option to check when many of your customers live outside the US. Its appeal is printing closer to those buyers. That is the main use of a printify vs printful vs gelato comparison. For a mostly US store it may not change the decision.
Gelato has a free tier, a paid Gelato+ plan and a custom Platinum plan. One June 2026 review puts Gelato+ at about $20 a month on annual billing. Reviews disagree on the monthly price and the discount, and Gelato's own pricing page blocked our check. Confirm both in your dashboard, then apply the same test: fee divided by discount.
Which one should you choose?
Choose Printify when a low base price and a choice of printers matter most. Pick Printful when you want fewer variables and published branding prices. Look at Gelato if most of your orders ship outside the US.
- Testing an idea with no orders: Either Free plan works, and both cost $0. Pick the one whose catalog carries your product, and skip the subscription for now.
- Building a brand: Printful's published label prices make the cost of branding easy to work out per order. You also have fewer printers to vet as you add products.
- Competing on price on Etsy: Printify's lower base price leaves more room in a crowded listing. Order samples first, since the cheapest provider may not be the one you want to keep.
- Selling mostly outside the US: Compare Gelato with a Printify provider near your customers. Price one full order to your largest market on each.
Where you sell matters as much as who prints, and Shopify vs Etsy is the comparison that covers that choice.
When neither is the right choice
Skip both if you sell a steady, predictable volume of the same few products. Bulk printing usually lowers the unit cost once demand is reliable, and you accept holding stock in exchange.
A store that depends on a high margin on basic products has the same problem. Print on demand trades margin for zero inventory. That trade stops making sense when your sales are predictable enough to buy ahead.
How to test before you sell
Order a sample from Printful and from two or three Printify providers before you list anything. Product photos cannot show you print quality, and the same design can come out differently from one print provider to the next.
Printful gives 20% off samples on the Free plan and 25% off on Growth, limited to 1 sample order a month with 3 items at most. That extra discount is too small a reason to subscribe. For Printify, check the current sample terms in your account.
Compare the samples on print sharpness, fabric and how they look after a wash. Note the order date and the arrival date, since that is the delivery time your customer will feel.
FAQ
Choosing between them
Is Printful or Printify better for beginners?
Printful is simpler because you have fewer printers to vet. Printify usually costs less per item but asks you to compare providers and order samples. Both are free to start, so the printful vs printify decision carries little risk at the beginning.
Is Printify cheaper than Printful?
On base price it often is. One September 2025 example put the same tee at $7.25 on Printify Premium and $12.95 on Printful. Prices vary by provider, and shipping and duty can narrow the gap, so compare a full order.
Can I use Printful and Printify on the same Shopify store?
Yes. Each connects to Shopify through its own app and fulfills only the products you created in it. Items from both in one cart ship separately, so check how that affects your shipping rates.
Plans, ownership and Gelato
Are Printful and Printify the same company now?
They share an owner, after a merger announced on November 5, 2024. The two brands and platforms still run separately under one holding company.
Is Printify Premium worth it?
Only once you spend about $195 a month on products with monthly billing, or about $125 with annual billing. Those figures assume the full 20% discount, so your real line is probably higher.
Is Gelato better than Printify or Printful?
It can be for stores with many customers outside the US. Printing closer to the buyer is its main appeal. Check Gelato's current plan prices yourself, because published reviews disagree.

Leave a Reply